D.R. Horton, one of the nation’s leading homebuilders, has faced several notable construction defect complaints and legal settlements over the years. Here are some significant examples:
South Carolina Settlement
In 2024, D.R. Horton, along with subcontractors and suppliers, agreed to a $16.1 million settlement in a class-action lawsuit involving more than 200 homes in Easley, South Carolina. Homeowners alleged various construction defects, including issues with roofs, I-joists, flashing, siding, and weather-resistant barriers, leading to water intrusion concerns.
Louisiana Class Action Lawsuit
Homeowners in Louisiana initiated a class-action lawsuit against D.R. Horton, Inc. – Gulf Coast, citing defective design and construction in new residential homes. Reported issues included excessive moisture and humidity levels, structural defects, and ineffective HVAC systems. The lawsuit also alleged inadequate responses to warranty claims and mandatory use of specific HVAC services, leading to ongoing damages for homeowners.
Midlands, South Carolina Lawsuits
As of January 2025, D.R. Horton is facing approximately 60 lawsuits in the Midlands region of South Carolina. The allegations involve various construction defects, such as issues with roofs, I-joists, flashing, siding, and weather-resistant barriers, with some defects reportedly causing water intrusion.
Nationwide Complaints
Homeowners across the nation have reported numerous construction-related concerns with D.R. Horton builds. Complaints include subpar finish work, exposed wood on roofs, improperly installed door frames, and drainage issues leading to flooding. Despite moving in months prior, many homeowners were still awaiting repairs, highlighting potential systemic issues in construction quality and customer service.
These cases underscore the importance of thorough inspections and due diligence when purchasing homes from large builders, as even prominent companies can encounter significant construction quality issues.
Note: The attorneys at Sauder Schelkopf were not involved in these matters.
Experience Matters
Sauder Schelkopf has a nationally recognized litigation practice. The firm currently serves as court-appointed lead counsel in courts across the country. The attorneys at Sauder Schelkopf have recovered over $1 billion on behalf of their clients and class members. Our firm was recognized by the Legal Intelligencer’s 2022 Professional Excellence Awards. The Legal Intelligencer’s Professional Excellence Awards honor Pennsylvania law firms and attorneys who have made a significant, positive impact on the legal profession. Our firm was named in the Litigation Departments of the Year (Specialty Area category; runner-up), an award that honors the best litigation practice in a small or mid-sized firm in Pennsylvania. This recognition was based on the firm’s 2021 litigation work and its important ongoing cases. LawDragon has recognized our attorneys in its list of the “500 Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers” for 2022. This list notes: “From the opioid epidemic to toxic substances and defective products, truck accidents to wildfires and sexual abuse, these are the lawyers who stand on the front line in individual lawsuits and class actions seeking justice.” Mr. Schelkopf was named to Pennsylvania’s Best Lawyers® 2022 for Class Actions/Mass Tort Litigation. The American Lawyer named Mr. Sauder to its 2021 Northeast Trailblazers. The honor recognizes 60 lawyers who are “truly agents of change.” It “recognizes professionals in the Northeast who have moved the needle in the legal industry.” The Legal Intelligencer named Mr. Sauder and Mr. Schelkopf in its 2020 Pennsylvania Trailblazers list recognizing 31 lawyers who “have taken extra measures to contribute to positive outcomes . . . and who are truly agents of change.” The Legal highlighted the firm’s innovative work on advocacy as class counsel in large institutional sex abuse cover-ups, women’s, and children’s rights. Our attorneys have also consistently been recognized by their peers being named to Pennsylvania SuperLawyer, a distinction held by the top 5% of attorneys in Pennsylvania. The National Trial Lawyers Association has also selected our attorneys as the Top 100 Trial Lawyers in Pennsylvania.
We Want to Hear from You
If you were impacted by a construction defect, you can contact the attorneys at Sauder Schelkopf by filling out the form on this page.
Our Firm litigates cases in federal and state courts throughout the United States. Many states and jurisdictions have statutes that make it unlawful for persons to hold themselves out as attorneys unless they are licensed to practice in that state. On occasions where our Firm or its attorneys practice in jurisdictions in which one of our attorneys is not licensed, we will associate with that court on a “for that case only” basis and/or associate with locally licensed counsel.